Handmade in Kalamazoo, eaten everywhere!

Cookie drop 101

  • Shop the Drop

    Cookies go on sale Saturdays at 9 a.m. EST

  • Place an Order

    Quantities are limited - first come, first served

  • Shipped Fast

    Get your cookies in just a few days

Small Batches, Big Flavors

Baked Fresh
Shipped Fast
Real Good Cookies
Gluten-Free Options

The mainstays

These are the cookies we bake on repeat. Fan favorites. Forever flavors. No notes.
  • Snickerdoodle (G.F.)

    Snickerdoodle (G.F.)

    $14.00+
    Sold Out
  • Molasses Spice (G.F.)

    Molasses Spice (G.F.)

    $14.00+
    Sold Out
  • Chocolate Chip (G.F.)

    Chocolate Chip (G.F.)

    $15.00+
    Sold Out
  • Baklava Bliss

    Baklava Bliss

    $15.00+
    Sold Out
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter (G.F.)

    Chocolate Peanut Butter (G.F.)

    $15.00+
    Sold Out
Some cookies don’t need a twist — they just need to be done right. This one’s soft, buttery, and dusted...

Seasonals

Limited-run cookies inspired by the moment, be it holidays, harvests, or sudden cravings.
  • S'Moke Show

    S'Moke Show

    $16.00
    Sold Out
  • Short & Sweet (G.F.)

    Short & Sweet (G.F.)

    $16.00
    Sold Out
  • ★★★★★
    “Every cookie from Kalamazoo Cookie Co. tastes like it was meant for a special occasion.”
    Colin D.
  • ★★★★★
    “I didn’t know it was possible to fall in love with a cookie but...”
    Summer C.
  • ★★★★★
    “5 stars for Kalamazoo Cookie Co! My favorites are the classic  chopped chocolate and the baklava bliss but you can’t go wrong with any flavor.”
    Jenna B.
  • ★★★★★
    “The Cinnamon Swirl cookie actually tastes like a cinnamon roll…So dang good!”
    Trey C.
  • ★★★★★
    “The texture of these cookies is absolutely perfect!”
    Jonah M.
  • ★★★★★
    “They were by far the biggest hit at our wedding dessert table!”
    Robin C.

  • Have a custom order?

    Planning something big? We’ve got you.

    Need a mountain of cookies for your event? A special batch just for you? Or maybe you've just accepted that moderation isn't your thing (no judgement.)

    While our Saturday drops have limits, we’re always happy to make room for custom orders—especially if you need 4 dozen or more.

    Weddings, birthdays, office parties, baby showers, or just a really specific craving—whatever it is, we’ll bake it fresh, by hand, with the same no-weird-stuff ingredients you know and love.

    Fill out the form below and we’ll get back to you with a quote, a timeline, and probably a compliment.

    Contact us

FAQ

Find the most frequently asked questions below.

  • Because you’re early… or late, depending how you look at it.

    We bake fresh in small batches, and our online shop only opens during the Cookie Drop — SATURDAYS at 9 A.M. EST — until we sell out. When the shop is closed, all cookies show as “Sold Out” to keep things fair for everyone.

    Pro tip: Set an alarm and jump on early — they go fast.

  • Each cookie weighs in at 75g (2.5 oz)—big enough to share, but we won’t judge if you don’t.

  • Our cookies stay fresh for about a week at room temperature. Keep them sealed in their original bag to maintain freshness. Avoid refrigerating them, as the cold can dry them out.

  • Yes, our cookies freeze and reheat well. For best results, place them in an airtight container before freezing. When you’re ready to enjoy them, follow our cookie care instructions to reheat.

  • No, but they are vegetarian.

  • Cookies go on sale SATURDAYS at 9 A.M. EST. Quantities are limited - first come, first served. Cookies are baked fresh & shipped out a few days later.